So this post is partially the product of a great deal of insomnia. It’s 1:16am and I still cannot sleep. Too many things on my mind, in addition to an overactive sense of night vision and night hearing (i.e. it’s neither dark enough nor silent enough for me to sleep)
But I’ve been hurting recently.
Every day I see these images of Palestinians suffering. I read these reports about how many Palestinians were killed and I cannot help but think that Israel is making a mistake.
Does Israel have the right to defend themselves? Absolutely.
Is what Israel doing in Palestine defense? Absolutely not.
Please don’t take this for anti-semitism, because it’s not. Excusing criticism of Israel merely as anti-semitism denigrates the torture and horrible oppression that Jewish people have undergone. Also, remember that Palestinians are actually included in the definition of Semitic people.
Israel should understand that you cannot fight violence with violence. In a boxing match both people end up injured, one person may win – but if a bout is too violent or prolonged, both fighters may be irreparably damaged – for life. Unfortunately, what is happening in Gaza is just that – it’s a prolonged battle.
But it isn’t the war, and just like the My Lai massacre in Vietnam entered the publics’ consciousness, this “incursion” into Gaza is beginning to be seen differently by the rest of the viewing world. It’s only adding anti-Israel fuel to the fire.
Ultimately, Israel only has so much political capital, and they are spending it rapidly, and unwisely I might add, on military solutions to something that can only be remedied politically. Much of Gaza is hopeless, which helps to explain their nihilistic election of Hamas. Hamas vowed to fight.
Israel also has vowed to fight.
What this conflict is, in reality, is a conflagration between fundamentalist Israelis, and fundamentalist Palestinians – with the larger body of moderate parties trapped in the middle. When the UN, Red Cross, and Amnesty International all ban together to either condemn or demand a country cease their violent actions, you know something horrific is happening.
Israel deserves to exist – without any doubt. But then again, Palestinians deserve to keep the land they’ve farmed and existed on for centuries. Palestinians deserve to have the chance to actually build infrastructure and viable governments.
When the Allies defeated Axis forces in World War II, they ensured that reconstruction was a major thrust of their post-conflict international policy. It’s what has made modern Germany, Italy, and Japan trade partners instead of terrorist supporting governments.
Israel, after their Seven Day war, should have probably forseen the writing on the wall. You don’t win enemies over by condemning them to an open air prison…Security in that region depends primarily on economic performance. Look at Saudia Arabia, United Arab Emirates, Jordan, Qatar, Egypt. They are all stable, secular countries. They have definite industries that are supporting them – and they are investing in the development of additional industries to supplant the oil industry as it inevitably wanes and withers over the next several decades. The problem nations in the Middle East have no economic future. They live in poverty and apartheid.
So the blockade of foreign aid: Food, clothing, fuel, medicine – must stop. Starving a caged animal doesn’t make them more likely to respect or agree with you, it makes them more likely to lash out at you.
Israel – stop making the same mistakes that the US is making in Iraq. Build schools, roads, infrastructure. Become a supporter of a Palestinian state before its’ too late.
Otherwise they might succeed in eradicating the Palestinian people. But it won’t be peace that they achieve. Instead it will be War Crimes charges.
In other news.
Oscar Grant, a 22 year old father of a four year old was shot. In the back. While he was lying face down. On the ground…
After a fight broke out on a train between ten people, the BART police in Oakland were called to calm the situation. They arrived and separated everybody it looked like.
Well soon thereafter, Mr. Grant was made to lie down on the ground, face down (in the middle of a subway platform – which is not a good place to be), and was then shot in the back. The ricocheting bullet ripped through his lungs and eventually, several hours later killed him.
The indignity was worsened by the fact that immediately after the shooting, they handcuffed the poor man, while leaving him face down on the ground.
BART Police then confiscated as many cell phones and cameras as they could. But they didn’t confiscate enough.
Then when video of the shooting leaked, they tried a sorry excuse saying the officer probably mistook his pistol for his Taser. Which as we know is a crock of garbage. Much like the officer.
Soon after, the officer resigned, retained an attorney, and hasn’t spoken with investigators, nor has he made a statement.
He also, conspicuously, hasn’t been charged with ANY crime yet. Now, I’ve been told if you have a weapon there are two cardinal rules:
1. Don’t take your weapon out if you don’t plan to shoot something
2. Don’t point your weapon at anything if you don’t want to kill it.
I honestly cannot think of a justifiable reason that this officer would have to kill Mr. Grant. I just can’t. Even if it was all a terrible mistake, his carelessness, the reckless indifference to the safety of the person who he was taking into custody is criminal. Especially given his training as a peace officer, it is unconscionable that he even drew his weapon.
So, to the citizens of the Bay Area – protest. Peacefully. Write letters to everyone on the Oakland City Council, the Alameda District Attorney, and the California State Attorney Generals’ Office. Write letters to the Bay Area Rapid Transit Authority
To the Citizens outside of the Bay Area. Write letters to the San Francisco Chamber of Commerce and Oakland Chamber of Commerce. Let them know that as long as justice isn’t done, we won’t be shopping or visiting Oakland or San Francisco. Put the pressure on them.
I for one, am tired of being fearful of police. I’m tired of seeing people who look just like me getting killed in various altercations with the police. I’m sick of seeing Al Sharptons’ ass marching. I’m sick of Sean Bells, Rodney Kings, and now Oscar Grants. Again, if the police think that the way to keep the peace is by shooting, beating, and arresting innocent black people they are sadly wrong.
Both of these issues are connected by one thing. Completely unnecessary violence. Counterproductive violence. Senseless violence.
Can we please for once, stop the violence?
Recent Comments